The reason a 60-year-old medical professor who killed his son threatening him with a weapon had his 4-year prison sentence confirmed

In a case where a 64-year-old medical professor killed his son after a physical struggle in which the professor was threatened with a weapon for about an hour, the Supreme Court has upheld a four-year prison sentence. Many people believe that if the party threatened first kills the other party, it would be recognized as self-defense; however, this was not the case. We will examine why the court ruled it a murder rather than an act of defense, and the criteria used to determine the sentence.

How did the course of events unfold?

A symbolic image reminiscent of the scene of an incident that occurred at a house in Goyang, Gyeonggi Province

This incident occurred in September 2025 at a residence in Goyang, Gyeonggi Province. Professor A, a 64-year-old medical school professor, was threatened with a weapon for about an hour by his son, who was in his 30s at the time, saying, "I will kill you.".

A physical altercation broke out amidst the continuing threats, and Mr. A stabbed his son in the neck with a piece of broken pottery. The son lost his life on the spot.

The prosecution indicted Mr. A on charges of murder. Both the first and second trials sentenced him to four years in prison, and the Third Division of the Supreme Court (presiding Justice Eom Sang-pil) dismissed the appeal on October 1, 2026, thereby finalizing the sentence.

If you were threatened first with a weapon, isn't that self-defense?

An image showing a weapon in hand, raising questions about whether self-defense applies.

Many people believe that if they are attacked or threatened first with a weapon, the consequences that occur while subduing the opponent are recognized as self-defense. However, the court's criteria for judgment are not that simple.

Self-defense under Article 21 of the Criminal Act is established only if it is a defensive act against an infringement that is 'currently' in progress. The appellate court determined that in the physical altercation that occurred after the son's assault had subsided, Mr. A actively attacked beyond the scope of defense.

In other words, self-defense is not determined solely by who raised the weapon first. The court separately considers whether the infringement was actually in progress and whether the response was within the scope necessary to prevent it.

Why was the intent to kill recognized?

An image showing a judge in robes deliberating on whether intent is recognized.

The court did not view Mr. A’s statement that he “thought that if he did not kill his son, he could die himself” as a denial of intent. Rather, it interpreted it as an explanation of the motive leading to the crime.

In addition, the court of first instance viewed the fact that stabbing the neck with a broken bowl could lead to a fatal injury as something even an ordinary person could foresee. The judgment also took into account that A, a current medical school professor, would have been able to foresee the outcome more clearly.

As such, the fact that the defendant's professional knowledge was referenced in determining whether the outcome could have been foreseen is a unique factor of this case. It is difficult to generalize that professional knowledge functions in the same way in all criminal cases.

How did the conflict between father and son deepen?

An image with a dark atmosphere suggesting a strained father-son relationship and deepening conflict

It is reported that the relationship between Mr. A and his son became strained during the process of disciplining his son for misbehavior during his school days. Since then, Mr. A only sent living expenses through his wife and rarely contacted his son directly.

The conflict deepened after Mr. A's wife, the son's mother, passed away in March 2025. The son expressed his anger, claiming that his father was responsible for his mother's death or that his father was trying to monopolize the inheritance.

However, these claims are merely allegations raised by the son's side, and the report did not include any confirmation that such facts were actually established. Unconfirmed claims should not be accepted as facts.

What were the mitigating circumstances for the four-year prison sentence?

An image symbolizing the confirmed sentence of 4 years in prison through a courthouse building and scales

The sentence of four years in prison for murder appears to be the result of reflecting mitigating circumstances. The court took into account that Mr. A committed the crime instantaneously and impulsively in a situation of extreme fear while being threatened with a weapon.

The fact that he endured his son's verbal abuse and physical violence for a long period while striving to fulfill his duties as a father also acted as a favorable circumstance. In addition, it is reported that the consistent statement by Mr. A's daughter, the victim's sole surviving family member, that she does not wish for punishment also influenced the sentencing decision.

Both the second trial and the Supreme Court upheld the first trial's framework of judgment. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the four-year prison sentence was finally confirmed.

The most noteworthy point in this ruling

The key point this case demonstrates is that the fact of being 'threatened first' does not itself serve as grounds for immunity. The court examines, as separate issues, whether the infringement was in progress and whether the response covered the scope of defense.

It is important to remember that when determining legal liability for extreme responses to domestic violence or threats, both the specific circumstances and the continuity of the actions are considered. If you find yourself in a similar situation, it is safer to seek advice from a legal expert rather than making hasty judgments.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is it not self-defense when you killed someone while being threatened with a weapon?

Self-defense is recognized only for defensive acts committed while an infringement is in progress. In this case, the court determined that there were acts exceeding the scope of defense during the physical struggle that occurred after the assault had subsided.

“Why wasn't the statement, "I felt like I would die if I didn't kill," accepted as intentional denial?

The court interpreted this remark not as a statement denying intent to kill, but as a remark explaining the motive leading to the crime.

Did his status as a medical school professor influence the ruling?

The court determined that while even a layperson could foresee that stabbing the neck with a broken bowl could result in a fatal injury, the defendant, a sitting medical school professor, could have known this even better. This judgment was applied specifically to this case, and the same standard is not applied to all cases.

What is the reason the 4-year prison sentence was finalized?

Following the first and second trials, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, and the sentence was finalized as is. It is reported that the impulsive nature of the crime due to momentary fear, the defendant's long patience, and the bereaved family's wish not to pursue punishment were taken into consideration when determining the sentence.

Were the dispute over the inheritance or the cause of the mother's death also revealed in this ruling?

No. These are merely claims made by the son during his lifetime, and the report does not include any separate factual verification regarding the actual inheritance dispute or the cause of the mother's death.

# Son murdered due to weapon threat # University medical school professor # 4-year prison sentence confirmed # Self-defense controversy # Patricide # Yonhap News

Leave a Comment